Author: Liat Steir-Livny
Institution: The Open University of Israel (Israel)
Year of publication: 2018
Source: Show
Pages: 406–413
DOI Address:
PDF: ppsy/47-2/ppsy2018218.pdf

Israeli culture in the 1940s and 1950s was dominated by ideological considerations. Zionist films, as other aspects of Eretz-Israel and Israeli culture, distinctively propagated Zionist ideas. As a consequence of their sociopolitical focus, these films neglected the complexities of the relationship between Holocaust survivors and the native Jews in Eretz Israel. Instead, Holocaust survivors were reduced to a homogeneous entity that bore distinct negative connotations. Films depicted female Holocaust survivors as mentally unstable, unfit mothers, and often played up negative sexual stereotypes. In these films, the women were “cured” or went through a process of “purification” thanks to the Zionist establishment. Historical research often cites the trial of Adolf Eichmann (1961) as being a turning point in the Israeli public’s perception of the Holocaust, and its representation in Israeli culture. This article will focus on an analysis of the film The Hero’s Wife (Peter Frye, 1963) that was produced in the aftermath of the trial. It will discuss the innovative representations of this unresearched film and will seek to answer the questions of why, and in what way, its narrative comprises a subversive antithesis to the narrative shaped by Zionist fiction films made prior to the Eichmann trial.


  • Avisar, I (1998). National anxiety, personal nightmares: The Holocaust complex in Israeli cinema. In: N. Gertz, O. Lubin & J. Ne’eman (eds), Fictiv Looks – On Israeli Cinema (pp. 160-178). Tel-Aviv: The Open University [Hebrew].
  • Bartov, O (1999). Kitsch and Sadism in Ka-Tzetnik’s Other Planet: Israeli Youth Imagine the Holocaust.” Alpayim 17, 148-175 [Hebrew]
  • Brutin, B (2005). From the Margin to the Mainstream – Israeli Art and the Holocaust. Massuah 33, 110-138 [Hebrew].
  • Gertz, N (1993). Motion Fiction: Israeli Fiction in Films. Tel-Aviv: the Open University Press [Hebrew].
  • Gertz, N (2004). A Different Chorus - Holocaust Survivors, Foreigners and Others in Israeli Cinema and Literature. Tel Aviv: Am Oved [Hebrew].
  • Geva, S (2010). To the unknown Sister. Tel-Aviv: Hakibutz haMeuhad [Hebrew].
  • Heineman, E. D (2002). Sexuality and Nazism: The Doubly Unspeakable? Journal of the History of Sexuality 11, 22-66.
  • Holtzman, A (2006). Loves of Zion: Studies in Modern Hebrew Literature. Jerusalem: Carmel [Hebrew].
  • Laor, D (1993). Changes to the Image of the Holocaust: Notes on the Literary Aspect. Katedra 69, 164-169 [Hebrew].
  • Levenkron, N (2008). Death and the Maidens: "Prostitution", Rape and Sexual Slavery during World War II. Theory and Criticism 15, 15-44 [Hebrew].
  • Peleg, Y (2006). Heroic conduct: Homoeroticism and the creation of Modern, Jewish Masculinity. Jewish Social Studies, Vol. 13, No 1, Fall, 31-58.
  • Pinchevski, A. & Liebes, T (2010). Severed Voices: Radio and the Mediation of Trauma in the Eichmann Trial. Public Culture 22(2), 265-291.
  • Porat, D (2011). The Smoke-Smelling Morning Coffee. Jerusalem: Yad vaShem: Am Oved, 2011. Print [Hebrew].
  • Ruby, T and Frye‎, P. (1995). Thelma and Peter, Life and Theatre - The Double Journey. Tel-Aviv: Zmora Bitan.
  • Segev, T (1991). The Seventh Million - The Israelis and the Holocaust. Jerusalem: Ceter, 1991 [Hebrew].
  • Shapira, A (1997). New Jews Old Jews.  Tel Aviv: Am Oved [Hebrew].
  • Steir-Livny, L (2009). Two Faces in the Mirror: the representation of Holocaust Survivors in Israeli Cinema 1945-2005. Jerusalem: Eshkolot-Magness [Hebrew].
  • Steir-Livny, L (2011). The threefold exile – the female Holocaust survivor in Israeli cinema. In: M. Shilo and G. Katz (eds). Gender in Israel – new studies on gender in the Yishuv and the state, Iyunim bitkumat Israel Thematic Series, Vol. 6. 497-520 [Hebrew].
  • Talmon, M (2001). Israeli Graffiti: Nostalgia in Israeli Cinema. Tel Aviv: Open University Press [Hebrew].
  • Tydor Baumel, J (1995). In Everlasting Memory: Individual and Communal Holocaust Commemoration in Israel. Israel Affairs 3, no. 1, 146-170;
  • Weitz, Y (1999). Between Catharsis and Knife-Fight: The ‘Eichmann Trial’ and the ‘Kasztner Trial’ and Their Influence on Israeli Society. In: D Gutwein & M. Mautner (eds). Law and History (pp. 395-421). Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Center for Jewish History [Hebrew].
  • Yablonka, H (2000). Contradictory Identities, complementary Identities: Holocaust survivors, the memory of the Holocaust and Israeli identity. Massuah 28, 301-317 [Hebrew].
  • Yablonka, H. The State of Israel vs. Adolf Eichmann. New York: Schocken, 2004.
  • Yosef, R (2010). Knowing a man – sexuality, manhood and ethnicity in Israeli cinema. Tel-Aviv: Sifriyat Poalim [Hebrew].
  • Zartal, I (2002) Death and the Nation: History, Memory, Politics. Or Yehuda: Dvir-Zmora Bitan [Hebrew].
  • Zimmerman, M (2002). Don't Touch My Holocaust. Haifa: Haifa University Press [Hebrew].


Wiadomość do:



© 2017 Adam Marszałek Publishing House. All rights reserved.

Projekt i wykonanie Pollyart