Edukacja liberalna we współczesnej myśli politycznej

Author: Janusz Grygieńć
Institution: Uniwersytet Mikołaja Kopernika w Toruniu
Year of publication: 2013
Source: Show
Pages: 7-27
DOI Address:
PDF: kie/96/kie9601.pdf

Liberal Education in the Contemporary Political Thought

The article is devoted to the problem of the place ascribed to liberal education (and most of all to humanities as constituting its essential part) in contemporary political thought. In times when many rightist as well as leftist thinkers diagnose a crisis of liberal democracy and its educational system, displaying much anxiety about the still-lowering level of citizens’ willingness to participate in a public sphere, some of them propose their diagnosis of such situation and postulates of reform aimed at raising the level of citizens’ engagement in democratic life. One of the means to achieving that goal is implementation of the idea of liberal education, which might work in favor of students’ character development, their acquisition of a holistic view of reality, and their consciousness of the fact of overlapping character of relations binding individual and communal wellbeing. The article aims at presenting theoretical ways of defending humanities in face of contemporary restatement of the role of liberal education in Western societies. The course of argument is following: firstly the transition made in XXth century from “liberal education” to “education to liberalism” (resulting in specialization and vocational character of science) will be traced. Then the opinions of critics to such model of education will be shown, focusing on the representatives of three political doctrines: republicanism, communitarianism and liberalism. In case of each of these group of thinkers their characteristic attitude towards humanities, will be displayed.


  • Adler M., Labor, Leisure and Liberal Education, „Journal of General Education” 1951, t. 6.
  • Adler M., Liberalism and Liberal Education, „Educational Record”, lipiec 1939.
  • Adler M., The Crisis in Contemporary Education, „The Social Frontier” 1939, nr 42, t. 5.
  • Arthur J., Bailey R., Schools and Community. The Communitarian Agenda in Education, London 2000.
  • Arum R., Roksa J., Academically Adrift . Limited Learning on College Campuses, Chicago 2011.
  • Atkinson W.P., Liberal Education of the Nineteenth Century, New York 1873.
  • Ayaz Naseem M., Hyslop-Margison E.J., Nussbaum’s Concept of Cosmopolitanism: Practical Possibility Or Academic Delusion? „Paideusis” 2006, nr 2, t. 15.
  • Bailey R., Arthur J., Schools and Community. The Communitarian Agenda in Education, London 2000.
  • Barber B., Strong Democracy. Participatory Politics for a New Age, Berkeley 1984.
  • Bloom A., The Failure of the University. Toward an Uncertain Future, „Daedalus” 1974, nr 4, t. 103.
  • Bloom A., Umysł zamknięty. O tym, jak amerykańskie szkolnictwo wyższe zawiodło demokrację i zubożyło dusze dzisiejszych studentów, Poznań 1997.
  • Bloom A., University Standards and the Decline of Human Learning [w:] The Western University on Trial, J.W. Chapman (red.), Berkeley–Los Angeles–London 1983.
  • Cowan T., Rethinking Citizenship Education. A Curriculum for Participatory Democracy, London 2009.
  • D’Souza D., Illiberal Education. The Politics of Race and Sex on Campus, New York 1991.
  • Eagleton T., Koniec teorii, Warszawa 2012.
  • Etzioni A., The Spirit of Community. Rights, Responsibilities and the Communitarian Agenda, New York 1993.
  • Etzioni A. i in., Character Building for a Democratic, Civil Society, Washington 1997.
  • Fisher E.T., Plan of Institutions Devoted to Liberal Education, New York 1881.
  • Galston W., Civic Education in the Liberal State [w:] Liberalism and the Moral Life, N.L. Rosenblum (red.), Cambridge Mass. 1989.
  • Galston W.A., Moral Guidance for Today’s Youth, in School and Out [w:] Rights and the Common Good. The Communitarian Perspective, A. Etzioni (red.), New York 1995.
  • Garforth F.W., Educative Democracy. John Stuart Mill on Education in Society, Oxford 1980.
  • Gitlin T., The Intellectuals and the Flag, New York 2006.
  • Grygieńć J., Między liberalizmem i republikanizmem. Obywatelstwo komunitarystyczne według Benjamina Barbera i Henry’ego Tama, „Studia Polityczne” 2013, nr 31 (w druku).
  • Grygieńć J., Wola powszechna w filozofii politycznej, Toruń 2012.
  • Gutmann A., Democratic Education, Princeton N.J. 1987.
  • Hutchins R.M., The Great Conversation: The Substance of Liberal Education, Chicago 1952.
  • Hyslop-Margison E.J., Ayaz Naseem M., Nussbaum’s Concept of Cosmopolitanism: Practical Possibility or Academic Delusion?, „Paideusis” 2006, nr 2, t. 15.
  • Kimball R., Tenured Radicals: How Politics Has Corrupted Higher Education, New York 1990.
  • Kymlicka W., Education for Citizenship [w:] Education in Morality, J.M. Halsted, T.H. McLaughlin (red.), London 1999.
  • Locke J., Myśli o wychowaniu, Wrocław–Kraków 1959.
  • Martin E.D., A Meaning of a Liberal Education, New York 1926.
  • Mill J.S., O rządzie reprezentatywnym. Poddaństwo kobiet, Kraków–Warszawa 1995.
  • Mill J.S., O wolności, Warszawa 1999.
  • Nussbaum M.C., Liberal Education and Global Community, „Liberal Education” 2004, nr 1, t. 90.
  • Nussbaum M.C., Not For Profit. Why Democracy Needs the Humanities, Princeton– –Oxford 2010.
  • Nussbaum M.C., W trosce o człowieczeństwo. Klasyczna obrona kształcenia ogólnego, Wrocław 2008.
  • Pangle T.L., Uszlachetnianie demokracji. Wyzwanie epoki postmodernistycznej, Kraków 1994.
  • Putnam R.D., Samotna gra w kręgle. Upadek i odrodzenie wspólnot lokalnych w stanach zjednoczonych, Warszawa 2008.
  • Roksa J., Arum R., Academically Adrift . Limited Learning on College Campuses, Chicago 2011.
  • Rorty R., Philosophy and Social Hope, Middlesex 1999.
  • Rorty R., Przygodność, ironia i solidarność, Warszawa 2009.
  • Rorty R., Wychowanie bez dogmatu, „Ameryka” 1990, zima (nr 236).
  • Strauss L., Sokratejskie pytania. Eseje wybrane, Warszawa 1998.
  • Sykes C., ProfScam. Professors and the Demise of Higher Education, New York 1988.
  • Tam H., Komunitaryzm. Nowy program polityczny i obywatelski, Toruń 2011.
  • Taylor O.H., Liberal Education and Liberalism, „Ethics” 1945, nr 2, t. 55.
  • West F., Short Papers on American Liberal Education, New York 1907.

Great Books civic virtue communitarianism liberal education humanities republicanism democracy liberalism

Message to:



© 2017 Adam Marszałek Publishing House. All rights reserved.

Projekt i wykonanie Pollyart