What Rule of Law for the European Union? – Tracing the Approaches of the EU Institutions

Although the rule of law is a normative notion, it requires a multidimensional approach. It speaks to important issues of law and politics, and its respect is essential for both legal and social security. It can be observed within the European Union (EU) where the issue of respect for the rule of law by its Member States has gained particular importance. The main goal of our study is to contribute to the academic discourse concerning the EU rule of law. The analysis particularly considers the approaches adopted by the EU institutions to the definition of this concept. Consequently, the first part of the article concentrates on difficulties in defining the rule of law. The second part presents the evolution of the Court of Justice approach toward this concept. The next part contains the analysis of the attitudes presented by other EU institutions in their documents. In the conclusions, it is underlined that although the approaches of the EU institutions towards the rule of have evolved, and they have tried to define it and indicate its main components, certain issues require clarification, e.g., the relations of the rule of law with other values.

REFERENCES:

• Apostolovska-Stepanoska, M., Runcheva Tasev, H., & Ognjanoska, H. (2020). Union based on the rule of law: the Court of Justice of the European Union and the (future of) European integration. Eastern Journal of European Studies 11(2), 396–426.
• Bedner, A. (2018). The promise of a thick view. In Ch. May & A. Winchester (Eds.), Handbook on the Rule of Law (pp. 34–47). Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
• Bonelli, M., Claes, M. (2018). Judicial serendipity: how Portuguese judges came to the rescue of the Polish judiciary: ECJ 27 February 2018, Case C-64/16. European Constitutional Law Review 14(3), 622–643.
• Belton, R.K. (2005). Competing Definitions of the Rule of Law: Implications for Practioners. Carnegie Papers 55. https://carnegieendowment.org/files/CP55.Belton.FINAL.pdf
• Closa, C. (2019). The politics of guarding the Treaties: Commission scrutiny of rule of law compliance. Journal of European Public Policy 26(5), 696–716. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2018.1477822
• Closa, C. (2016). Reinforcing EU monitoring of the Rule of Law: Normative Arguments, Institutional Proposals and the Procedural Limitations. In C. Carlos, & D. Kotcenov (Eds.), Reinforcing rule of law oversight in the European Union (pp. 15–35). Cambridge University Press.
• Costamaga, F. (2016). The Court of Justice and the Demise of the Rule of Law in the EU Economic Governance: The Case of Social Rights. Carlo Alberto Notebooks,
• Craig, P. (2019). Definition and Conceptualisation of the Rule of Law and the Role of Judicial Independence Therein. In P. Craig, S. Adam, N.D. Abad, & L. Salazar, Rule of Law in Europe – Perspectives from Practitioners and Academics (pp. 1–14). European Judicial Training Network.
• Dworkin, R. (1985). A Matter of Principle. Harvard University Press.
• Gajda-Roszczynialska, K., Markiewcz, K. (2020). Disciplinary Proceedings as an Instrument for Breaking the Rule of Law in Poland. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 12, 451–483.
• Halmai, G. (2019). The Possibility and Desirability of Rule of Law Conditionality. Hague Journal on the Rule Law 11, 171–188. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40803-018-0077-2
• Kochenov, D. (2019). Elephants in the Room: The European Commission's 2019 Communication on the Rule of Law. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 11, 423–438. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40803-019-00126-x
• Kochenov, D. (2015). The Missing EU Rule of Law? In C. Closa & D. Kochenov (Eds.), Reinforcing Rule of Law Oversight in the European Union (pp. 290–312). Cambridge University Press.
• Kochenov, D. (2009). The EU Rule of Law: Cutting Paths through Confusion. Erasmus Law Review 2(1), 5–24.
• Kochenov, D., Pech, L. (2015). Monitoring and Enforcement of the Rule of Law in the EU: Rhetoric and Reality. European Constitutional Law Review 11(3), 512–540. doi:10.1017/S1574019615000358
• Krygier, M, Winchester, A. (2018). Arbitrary power and the ideal of the rule of law. In Ch. May & A. Winchester (Eds.), Handbook on the Rule of Law. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
• Lautenbach, G. (2013). The Concept of the Rule of Law and the European Court of Human Rights. Oxford University Press.
• Magen, A. (2016). Cracks in the Foundations: Understanding the Great Rule of Law Debate in the EU. Journal of Common Market Studies 54(5), 1–12. DOI: 10.1111/jcms.12400
• Møller, J. (2018). The Advantages of a Thin View. In Ch. May & A. Winchester (Eds.), Handbook on the Rule of Law (pp. 21–33). Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
• Møller, J., Skaaning, S.E. (2014). The Rule of Law. Definitions, Measures, Patterns and Causes. Palgrave Macmillan.
• Oliver, P., Stefanelli, J. (2016). Strengthening the Rule of Law in the EU: The Council's Inaction. Journal of Common Market Studies 54(5), 1075–1084. DOI: 10.1111/jcms.12402
• Palombella, G. (2015). Beyond Legality – Before Democracy. Rule of Law Caveats in the EU Two-Level System. In C. Closa & D. Kochenov (Eds.), Reinforcing Rule of Law Oversight in the European Union (pp. 36–58). Cambridge University Press.
• Pech, L. (2009). The Rule of Law as a Constitutional Principle of the European Union. Jean Monnet Working Paper 4, 1–79.
• Pech, L. (2013). Rule of law as a guiding principle of the European Union's external action. CLEER Working Papers 3, 1–56.
• Pech, L., Platon, S. (2018). Judicial Independence Under Threat: The Court of Justice to the Rescue in the ASJP Case (Case C-64/16, Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses, Judgment of the Court of Justice (Grand Chamber) of 27 February 2018, EU:C:2018:117). Common Market Law Review 55, 1827–1854.
• Raz, J. (1979). The Rule-of-law and its Virtue. In R. Cunningham (Ed.) Liberty and the Rule of-law (pp. 3–21). Texas A&M University Press.
• Reding, V. (2013). The EU and the Rule of Law – What next? Speech at the Centre for European Policy Studies, Brussels 4 September 2013, SPEECH/13/677. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-13-677_de.htm
• Reid, A.S. (2020). The Rule of Law, the UK's Advocate-General and Brexit. https://dcubrexitinstitute.eu/2020/09/the-rule-of-law-the-uks-advocate-general-and-brexit/
• Ruffert, M. (2011). The European Debt Crisis and European Union Law. Common Market Law Review 48, 1777–1806.
• Tamanaha, B.Z. (2004). On the Rule of Law. History, Politics, Theory. Cambridge University Press.
• Viterbo, A. (2016). Legal and Accountability Issues Arising from the ECB's Conditionality. European Papers 1, 501–531.
• Von (2014). The Rule of Law in the Recent Jurisprudence of the ECJ. Fordham International Law Journal 37(5), 1311–1347.