Legitimacy and Nationalism in the Central Asian States: A Case of Kazakhstan in the Context of the War in Ukraine

This paper aims to analyze selected mechanisms accompanying the processes of national revival in the Central Asian republics after the collapse of the Soviet Union. The idea is to investigate the authorities’ actions, which legitimized themselves by appealing to national issues and controlling the processes of building national consciousness. The paper also covers the changes in the nationalist narrative in Kazakhstan in the context of the war in Ukraine, showing the tensions over national identities and loyalties. Some Kazakhs supported Russian aggression against Ukraine, to the great disappointment of national patriots, which has sparked a debate about how the “us” vs. “them” division should be understood in the face of war and a possible threat from Russia. Some participants in the debate question the reliability of equating national identity with loyalty to the state. In doing so, they challenge the government’s primordial narrative, in which nationality legitimizes or naturalizes the current configuration of political power.

REFERENCES:

• Airan (2023a). Kontsert Kamyziakov otmeniat? Musagaliev – vatnik? Dorokhov, KVN, petitsiia, Arsen Tusupbekov, 13.09.2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hlt3mcafMyM
• Airan (2023b). Saburov vs Skriptonit! Kak prodalis – Rossii nashi zvezdy? Chebatkov, Beisekeev, Musagaliev, TNT, 23.09.2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8o_ycdBwpc
• Altai, A.  (2023). Toқtat, zheңіs! 10.09.2023. https://www.facebook.com/aza.azamatuly/posts/pfbid027imcT9LnT3wCdmpfB7PRo1RxYZzNAy3U9v9QM3xYRezan2HNdHuy4u8aHtm9MtFvl
• Anceschi, L. (2015). The End of the Nazarbayev’s Dream, Open Democracy, 16.11.2015. https://www.opendemocracy.net/luca-anceschi/end-of-nazarbayev-dream
• Anderson, B. (1997). Wspólnoty wyobrażone: rozważania o źródłach i rozprzestrzenianiu się nacjonalizmu. Znak.
• Andreeva, D. (2023). Musagaliev i Dorokhov priniali uchastie v kontserte na Donbasse, 9.09.2023. https://forbes.kz/actual/musagaliev_i_dorohov_dali_kontsert_na_donbasse/
• Beetham, D. (2013). The Legitimation of Power (2nd edition). Palgrave Macmillan.
• Calhoun, C. (2007). Nacjonalizm. Wydawnictwo Akademickie i Profesjonalne.
• Cooley, A., & Heathershaw, J. (2017). Dictators Without Borders: Power and Money in Central Asia. Yale University Press.
• Demografiialyқ statistika (2023). Kazakstan Respublikasy khalkynyi sany (2023zh.basyna), 21.04.2023. https://stat.gov.kz/industries/social-statistics/demography/publications/9412/
• Dobson, W. J. (2012). The Dictator’s Learning Curve: Inside the Global Battle for Democracy. Anchor.
• Etnograficheskoe obozrenie. (2005). Spetsial-naia tema nomera: Arkheologiia uzbekskoi identichnosti, (1).
• Fedorov, E. (2020). YouTube Belrusinfo, 20.12.2020. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muz9qQUOvcw
• Freedman, E. (2009). When a democratic revolution isn’t democratic or revolutionary: Press restraints and press freedoms after Kyrgyzstan’s Tulip Revolution. Journalism, 10(6), 843–861. DOI: 10.1177/146488490934448
• Gerschewski, J. (2013), The Three Pillars of Stability: Legitimation, Repression, and Co-optation in Autocratic Regimes. Democratization, 20(1), 13–38. DOI: 10.1080/13510347.2013.738860
• Giperborei (2023). «Kamyziaki» v pravitel-stve i biznese RK? Spetsvypusk, 18.09.2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TzpV5tDPnGU
• Hobsbawm, E., & Ranger, T.  (Eds.) (2008). Tradycja wynaleziona. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.
• Il-khamov, A. (Ed.) (2002). Etnicheskii atlas Uzbekistana. Institut «Otkrytoe obshchestvo».
• Karimov, I. A. (1992a). Uzbekistan – svoi put – obnovleniia i progressa. Tashkent. Karimov, I. A. (1992b). Uzbekistan gosudarstvo s velikim budushchem.
• Karimov, I. A. (1993a). Ne postroiv novyi dom – ne razrushai starogo. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1993b). Uzbekistan: sobstvennaia model – perekhoda na rynochnye otnosheniia. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1995a). Solntse druzhby nashei svetit iz glubin tysiacheletii. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1995b). Uzbekistan na puti uglubleniia rynochnykh preobrazovanii. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1997). Uzbekistan na poroge KhKhI veka: ugrozy bezopasnosti, usloviia i garantii progressa. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1998). Ideologiia – eto obieediniaiushchii flag natsii, obshchestva, gosudarstva. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (1999). Uzbekistan ustremlennyi v KhKhI vek. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (2000). Nasha vysshaia tsel – nezavisimost – i protsvetanie Rodiny, svoboda i blagopoluchie naroda. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (2005). Nasha glavnaia tsel – demokratizatsiia i obnovlenie obshchestva, reformirovanie i modernizatsiia strany. Tashkent.
• Karimov, I. A. (2006). Obespechenie interesov cheloveka, sovershenstvovanie sotsial-noi zashchity – nasha prioritetnaia zadacha. Tashkent.
• Kassymbekova, B., & Marat, E. (2022). Pora otkazat-sia ot mifa imperskoi nevinnosti Rossii. PONARS Eurasia Policy Memo, 04.2022, 771.
• Keosayan, T. (2022). Litsemernye znamenitosti. Zapret georgievskoi lenty. Povedenie postsovetskikh stran. “RKN Free”, Roskomnadzor free, 24.04.2022. https://rutube.ru/video/25e45d41b67c883a63c 0bdeaca07ec5d/
• Kertzer, D. (2010). Rytuał, polityka, władza. Oficyna Wydawnicza VOLUMEN.
• Kurzman, C. (1999). Uzbekistan: The Invention of Nationalism in an Invented Nation. Critique: Critical Middle Eastern Studies, 8(15), 77–98. DOI: 10.1080/10669929908720151
• Laruelle, M. (2021). Central Peripheries. Nationhood in Central Asia. UCL Press.
• Lee, O. (2023). Vazhno‼14.09.2023, https://www.instagram.com/p/CxKTqC1tv80/
• Lemon, E. (2019). Weaponizing Interpol, Journal of Democracy, 30(2), 15–29.
• Lemon, E. (2022). Securitization of religion in Central Asia. In R. Isaacs & E. Marat (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Contemporary Central Asia. Routledge. DOI: 10.4324/9780429057977-28
• Lemon, E., & Thibault, H. (2018). Counter-extremism, Power and Authoritarian Governance in Tajikistan. Central Asian Survey, 37(1), 137–159, DOI: 10.1080/02634937.2017.1336155
• Lewis, D. (2011). Sovereignty after Empire: The Colonial Roots of Central Asian Authoritarianism. In S. Cummings & R. Hinnebusch (Eds.), Sovereignty After Empire: Comparing the Middle East and Central Asia (pp. 178–196). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
• Litvinova, M., & Chernykh, A. (2021). V boi idut odni istoriki. Senatory obsudili s chinovnikami nedavnee proshloe i vozmozhnoe budushchee. Kommersantie, 31.03.2021, 55. https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4751929
• March, A. F. (2002). The Use and Abuse of History: “National Ideology” as Transcendental Object in Islam Karimov’s “Ideology of National Independence”. Central Asian Survey, 21(4). DOI: 10.1080/0263493032000053190
• March, A. F. (2003). From Leninism to Karimovism: Hegemony, Ideology, and Authoritarian Legitimation. Post-Soviet Affairs, 19(4), 307–336. DOI: 10.2747/1060-586X.19.4.307
• Musagaliev, A. (2022). OVR Shou: Relokatsiia (feat. Ol-ga Buzova), 19.11.2022. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiUh3cCatm4
• Nazarbaev, N. (2015). Bіz – Ұly Dalanyң mұragerlerіmіz! 11.09.2015. https://kaz.inform.kz/news/nnazarbaev-biz-uly-dalanyn-muragerlerimiz_a2816958/
• Natsional-nyi sostav Rossii. (2020). https://www.statdata.ru/nacionalnyj-sostav-rossii
• Nikonov, V. (2020). Territoriia Kazakhstana – eto podarok ot Rossii, 12.12.2020. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFYu1IPDfLc
• Putin, V. (2014). Putin otvetil na vopros o Kazakhstane, 29.08.2014. https://tengrinews.kz/sng/putinotvetil-na-vopros-o-kazahstane-260975/
• Richter, A. (2008). Post-Soviet Perspective on Censorship and Freedom of The Media: An Overview. International Communication Gazette, 70(5), 307–324.
• Satpaev, D. (2023). Pro krizis v ODKB, konflikt v Karabakhe, inoagentov v Kazakhstane i razvorot Kyrgyzstana, BILD na russkom, 28.09.2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUQipksQOjQ
• Savchenko, I. (2010). Turkmenbashi bol-she ne budet sledovat – za solntsem. Russkaia sluzhba Bi-bi-si, 18.01.2010 http://www.bbc.com/russian/international/2010/01/100118_turkmen_monument_removal.shtml
• Schlumberger, O. (2010). Opening Old Bottles in Search of New Wine: On Non-democratic Legitimacy in the Middle East. Middle East Critique, 19(3), 233–250. DOI: 10.1080/19436149.2010.514473
• Shukuralieva, N. (2018). Bezpieczeństwo regionalne – integracja obronna państw Azji Centralnej. Sprawy Międzynarodowe, 4, 179–194. DOI: 10.35757/SM.2018.71.4.10
• Shukuralieva, N., & Lipiński, A. (2016). Wybrane mechanizmy legitymizacji władzy w krajach Azji Centralnej. In J. W. Adamowski, T. Wallas, & K. Kakareko (Eds.), Między Klio a Themis. Księga dedykowana Profesorowi Jackowi Sobczakowi (pp. 809–821). Silva Rerum.
• Smith, A. (2009). Kulturowe podstawy narodów. Hierarchia, przymierze i republika. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.
• The Village Kazakhstan. (2023). Kazakhstantsy trebuiut otmenit – kontserty komandy KVN “Kamyziaki” v Astane i Almaty, 12.09.2023. https://www.the-village-kz.com/village/city/news-city/32301-kazahstantsy-trebuyut-otmenit-kontserty-komandy-kvn-kamyzyaki-v-astane-i-almaty
• Toropova, I. (2023). Petitsiia za otmenu kontsertov komandy «Kamyziaki» v Kazakhstane, Alash online, 11.09.2023. https://alash.online/1627-otmena.html
• Wedeen, L. (1999). Ambiguities of Domination. Politics, Rhetoric, and Symbols in Contemporary Syria. University of Chicago Press.
• Zhir-Lebed, M. (2022). Rising Civic Awareness through Local Instagram: Young Kazakhstani Russians and Their Belongingness to Kazakhstan. Central Asian Affairs, 9(1), 67–93. DOI: 10.30965/22142290-12340016