India as the Vishwaguru and a Challenge to the Liberal International Order

  • Author: Patryk Kugiel
  • Institution: University of Warsaw (Poland)
  • ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8605-1391
  • Year of publication: 2024
  • Source: Show
  • Pages: 65–78
  • DOI Address: https://doi.org/10.15804/ppsy202442
  • PDF: ppsy/53-4/ppsy2024404.pdf

India’s role in the post-Cold War liberal international order (LIO) has primarily been examined in terms of whether it can become a revisionist or status quo power, both politically and economically. However, the concept of India as a ‘Vishwaguru’ (world teacher), promoted by the BJP government of Narendra Modi since 2014, projects India as a source of norms and principles that can govern international relations. This raises the question of how this new proposal might affect the LIO? Using a ‘normative power’ concept, this chapter seeks to understand the ‘Vishwaguru’ as an alternative proposition of ordering international system. It looks at critical government and ruling party documents, speeches by BJP leaders and supporters, and existing literature to better understand the rationale and goals of this new approach. It finds that India is thereby undermining Western dominance of the global discourse on the international system and poses a normative challenge to the political and economic LIO. While India’s approach reveals its ambitions for global power, it also contains essential flaws and contradictions that will limit the effectiveness of this strategy.

REFERENCES:

  • Al Jazeera (2024), “Modi’s India plans its own democracy index, after global rankings downgrade”, 21 March.
  • Bhagwat, M. (2014), “Full Text of Speech by RSS Sarasangchalak Mohan Bhagwat on Vijaya Dashmi 2014, Nagpur, Samvada, 22 October.
  • BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) (2014), Ek Bharat, Shrestha Bharat: Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas – Election Manifesto 2014, New Delhi: BJP.
  • BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) (2019), Sankalpit Bharat, Sahakt Bharat, BJP Election Manifesto 2019, New Delhi: BJP.
  • BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) (2024), Modi ki Guarantee 2024, BJP Manifesto. New Delhi: BJP.
  • Dalrymple, W. (2024), The Golden Road : How Ancient India Transformed the World, Blumsburry Publishing.
  • Sullivan de Estrada, K. (2023), “What is a vishwaguru? Indian civilizational pedagogy as a transformative global imperative”, International Affairs, 99(2), pp. 433–455.
  • Dormandy, X. (2007), “Is India, or Will It Be, a Responsible Stakeholder?.” Washington Quarterly.
  • Dzhaparova E. (2023), ‘We call Indi Vishwaguru’ Ukraine pushes for Delhi’s greater role in crisis”, Hindustan Times, April 10.
  • Guha, R. (2024), “Why India’s claims of being vishwaguru are foolish fantasies”, Scroll.in, 25.08.2024, https://scroll.in/article/1072394/ramachandra-guha-why-indias-claims-to-be-vishwaguru-are-foolishfantasies
  • Haidar, S. (2021), “India is the mother of all democracies, says Modi at U.N. General Assembly”, The Hindu, 26 September.
  • Hall, I. (2015), “Normative Power India?”, in: J. Gaskarth (ed.), China, India and the Future of International Society, Rowman&Littlefield: London, New York, 89–104.
  • Hall, I. (2017), “Narendra Modi and India’s normative power”, International Affairs, 93(1), 113–131.
  • Hall, I. (2019a), Modi and the Reinvention of Indian Foreign Policy, Bristol University Press.
  • Hall, I. (2019b), “India’s New Religious Diplomacy,” International Studies Perspectives 20(12).
  • Hall, I. (2023), “The Hindu Right and India’s Religious Diplomacy: Transatlantic Policy Network on Religion and Diplomacy”, Policy Brief #4.
  • Ikenberry G. J. (2009), „Liberal Internationalism 3.0: America and the Dilemmas of Liberal World Order”, Perspectives on Politics, 7(1), 71–87.
  • Ikenberry G. J. (2011), „The Future of Liberal World Order: Internationalism after America”, Foreign Affairs, 90(3), 56–68.
  • Ikenberry G. J. (2018), „The End of Liberal International Order?”, International Affairs, 94(1), 7–23.
  • India Today (2024), “Jaishankar says ‘international Khan Market gang’ trying to influence Indian voters”, May 24.
  • Indian Express (2021), “Jaishankar on global democracy downgrade: ‘Custodians can’t stomach we don’t want their approval”, March 15, 
  • Kugiel P. (2017), India’s Soft Power: a New Foreign Policy Strategy, Routledge: London, New York.
  • Kugiel P. (2019), „India, the European Union and the Postwar Liberal Order”, [in:] Rajendra K. Jain (red.), India and the European Union in a Turbulent World, Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan, 27–58.
  • Kugiel P. (2021), „From Destroyer to Preserver? The Evolution of India’s Position Towards the Liberal International Order and Its Significance for the EU-India Strategic Partnership”, [in:], Ph. Gieg et all, (ed.), EU-India Relations. The Strategic Partnership in the Light of the European Union Global Strategy, Springer, 253–274.
  • Kuźniar, R. (2022), Zmierzch liberalnego porządku 2011–2021, Wydawnictwo Naukowe Scholar: Warszawa.
  • Lekhi, M. (2023), “Address by Minister of State for External Affairs, Smt. Meenakashi Lekhi at the Raisina Dialogue 2023”, MEA: New Delhi, March 04.
  • Modi, N. (2014a), “Full Text: Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s speech on 68th Independence Day, Indian Express, 16 August.
  • Modi, N. (2014b), :English rendering of Prime Minister’s Statement at the General Debate of the 69th Session of the UNGA”, 27 September.
  • Modi, N. (2017), “Inaugural address by Prime Minister at second Raisina Dialogue”, MEA: New Delhi, 17 January.
  • Modi, N. (2018) “Prime Minister’s Statement on the subject ‘’Creating a Shared Future in a Fractured Word’’ in the World Economic Forum” (January 23, 2018), MEA: New Delhi, January 23.
  • Modi, N. (2021a), “Prime Minister’s Address at the UN General Assembly”, MEA: New Delhi, September 25,
  • Modi, N. (2021b), ”National Statement by Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi at COP26 Summit in Glasgow”, November 02, MEA: New Delhi.
  • Modi, N. (2022), “Our G-20 mantra is – One Earth, One Family, One Future: PM Modi”, https://www. narendramodi.in/
  • Modi, N. (2023), “Human-Centric Globalisation: Taking G20 to the Last Mile, Leaving None Behind – Narendra Modi”, Prime Minister’s Office, 07 September. 
  • Mohan C. R. (2010), “Rising India: Partner in Shaping the Global Commons”, The Washington Quarterly, 33(3), 133–148.
  • Naidu, V. (2018), “Make India Vishwaguru again”, The Indian Express, September 5.
  • Naidu, V. (2020), “India was known as ‘vishwa guru’, must regain its intellectual leadership: Venkaiah Naidu”, The Economic Times, Augugust 19.
  • Naidu, V. (2022), “Vice President calls for making India a Vishwaguru once again in the education sector”, Press Information Bureau, Government of India, Vice President’s Secretariat, 01 March.
  • Nayar B.R, Paul T.V. (2003), India in the World Order: Searching for Major-Power Status, Cambridge University Press.
  • Saran S. (2018), “India’s Role in a Liberal Post-Western World”, The International Spectator, 53(1), pp. 92–118.
  • Sidhu W. P. S., Mehta P.B., Jones B. (ed. 2013), Shaping the Emerging World. India and the Multilateral Order, Brookings Institution Press: Washington D.C..
  • Skolimowska, A. (2015), “The European Union as a ‘Normative Power’ in International Relations. Theoretical and Empirical Challenges”, Yearbook of Polish European Studies, Vol. 18, p. 111–129.
  • Slobodchikoff M. O., A. A. Tandon (2022), India as kingmaker : status quo or revisionist power, University of Michigan Press.
  • Tharoor, S. (2024), “India, liberalism and its crisis of legitimacy”, The Hindu, May 30, p. 6.
  • Thussu, D. K. (2013), Communicating India’s Soft Power: Buddha to Bollywood, Palgrave Macmillan.
  • VIF (2022), India’s Contribution to World Thought and Culture, Vivekananda International Foundation, Delhi: Aryan Books International
  • Zajączkowski J. (2008), Indie w stosunkach międzynarodowych, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Scholar.

normative power Vishwaguru Liberal International Order global order West India

Message to:

 

 

© 2017 Adam Marszałek Publishing House. All rights reserved.

Projekt i wykonanie Pollyart