Why Did “the Bulldozer” Want to Run Over the Women? Contextualization of Anti-Women Rhetoric in Tanzanian Politics under John Magufuli

This article examines the transformation of political discourse on women’s rights and women-oriented NGOs in Tanzania, focusing on successive state administrations within the same political party, led by John Pombe Magufuli and Jakaya Kikwete. The analysis unfolds through three key phases: first, characterizing the habitus of Tanzanian women’s NGOs; second, examining the evolving narratives in government-NGO relations; and third, briefly exploring the political discourse during the Kikwete and Magufuli presidencies. The research methodology is based on extensive desk research and two field studies conducted in Tanzania. Rather than adhering to a preconceived theory, our research approach is guided by theorems and selected frameworks. Pierre Bourdieu’s theoretical concepts, particularly ‘habitus’ and the ‘exchangeability of different forms of capital,’ underpin our argument and interpretation of the data. The study shows that while elements of anti-feminism are evident in Magufuli’s political discourse, accusations of promoting toxic masculinity are mainly unfounded. At the same time, it argues that the critique of women’s empowerment and women-focused NGOs can be attributed to Magufuli’s unique mode of accumulating political and economic capital, leading to heightened distrust in the relationship between these NGOs and the Tanzanian government.

REFERENCES:

• Anyimadu, A. (2016). Politics and Development in Tanzania (Research Paper). The Royal Institute of African Affairs, Chatham House.
• Arendt, C. M. (2018). From Critical Mass to Critical Leaders: Unpacking the Political Conditions behind Gender Quotas in Africa. Politics & Gender, 14(3), 295–322.
• Bourdieu, P. (1990). The Logic of Practice. Stanford University Press.
• Bourdieu, P., & Wacquant, L. J. D. (2001). Zaproszenie do socjologii refleksyjnej. Oficyna Naukowa.
• Bourdieu, P., & Passeron, J.-C. (2011). Reprodukcja. Elementy teorii systemu nauczania. PWN.
• Bourdieu, P. (2020). Habitus and Field. General Sociology. Volume 2. Lectures at the College de France (1982–1983). Polity Press.
• Baldwin, D. (Ed.) (1993). Neo-realism and Neo-liberalism: The Contemporary Debate. Columbia University Press.
• BBC. (2016, November 4). What has Tanzania’s Magufuli done during his year in office? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-37822740
• BBC. (2020, June 18). Tanzania’s John Magufuli – the man vowing to defeat coronavirus and imperialism. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-52983563
• BBC. (2021, March 18). John Magufuli: Tanzania’s late president in his own words. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-56441421
• Bebbington, A. (2007). Progress report. Social capital and development studies II: can Bourdieu travel to policy? Progress in Development Studies, 7(2), 155–162.
• Cela, B., Dankelman, I., & Stern, J. (2014). Bookshelf: Powerful Synergies: Gender Equality, Economic Development and Environmental Sustainability. Reproductive Health Matters, 22(43), 197–199.
• Boryczka, J. M. (2020). Attitudes Toward LGBT People and Rights in Africa. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics.
• Bratton, M. (1989). The politics of government-NGO relations in Africa. World Development, 17(4), 569–575.
• Cheeseman, N., Matfess, H., & Amani, A. (2021). Tanzania: The Roots of Repression. Journal of Democracy, 32(2), 77–89.
• Cichecka, A. (2018). NGO sector in relations to political situation in Tanzania. The Yearbook of International Security, 12(1), 163–172.
• Citizen (2017, June 22). Tanzania president vows not to allow teen mothers back to school. https://www.thecitizen.co.tz/News/Tanzania-president-vows-not-to-allow/1840340-3982906-u4rh24z/index.html
• Chwedczuk-Szulc, K., & Polus, A. (2020). Social Constructivism as Forecasting Matrix. Collective Habitus in International Relations. Polish Political Science Review, 8(1), 1–19.
• Corey-Boulet, R. (2018). How Magufuli Is Running Roughshod Over Women’s Rights in Tanzania. World Politics Review.
• Costa, C., & Murphy, M. (2015). Bourdieu and the Application of Habitus across the Social Sciences. In C. Costa & M. Murphy (Eds.), Bourdieu, Habitus and Social Research. The Art of Application. New York: Palgrave.
• Deloitte. (2016). Tanzania. A Leader among Africa’s Emerging Markets. Deloitte.
• Faludi, S. (1991). Backlash: The Undeclared War Against American Women. New York: Crown.
• Fowler, A. (1991). The Role of NGOs in Changing State]Society Relations: Perspectives from Eastern and Southern Africa. Development Policy Review, 9(1), 53.84.
• Harris, M. (2021, February 5). Unfinished Business: Magufuli’s Autocratic Rule in Tanzania. CSIS. https://www.csis.org/analysis/unfinished-business-magufulis-autocratic-rule-tanzania
• Harvey, D. (2005). A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Gray, H. (2015). The political economy of grand corruption in Tanzania. African Affairs, 114(456), 382–403.
• International Monetary Fund. (2005). Regional Economic Outlook: Sub-Saharan Africa. Washington: International Monetary Fund.
• International Republican Institute. (2016, October 25). IRI Gender Assessment in Tanzania Analyzes Women’s Political Participation. https://www.iri.org/news/iri-gender-assessment-in-tanzania-analyzes-womens-political-participation/
• Jackson, R. H., & Rosberg, C. G. (1984). Personal rule: theory and practice in Africa. Comparative Politics, 16(4), 421–442.
• Kabendera, E. (2015, January 28). Tanzania cabinet reshuffled as energy scandal claims fourth politician. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2015/jan/28/tanzaniacabinet-reshuffle-energy-scandal-jakaya-kikwete
• Kelsall, T. (2002). Donors, NGOs & the State. In O. Barrow, & M. Jennings (Eds.), The Charitable Impulse: NGOs and Development in East and North-East Africa (pp. 133–148). Oxford: James Currey.
• Kevane, M. (2004). Women and Development in Africa: How Gender Works. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
• Klein, N. (2007). The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. New York: Metropolitan Books.
• Komba, N. (2019). Macho, macho man: A toxic form of masculinity has infected politics in Tanzania. Democracy is on the line. Index on Censorship, 48(4), 45–47.
• Kwayu, A. (2021, March 18). Tanzania’s John Magufuli: a brilliant start but an ignominious end. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/tanzanias-john-magufuli-a-brilliant-start-but-anignominious-end-157092
• Lange, S., Wallevik, H., & Kiondo, A. (2000). Civil society in Tanzania. Chr. Michelsen Institute.
• Madon, S. (1999). International NGOs: networking, information flows and learning. The Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 8(3), 252–255.
• Madaha, R. M. (2014). Organized and gendered media advocacy at the centre of the feminist movement in a patriarchal Tanzania. Africa Review, 6(1), 18–29.
• Makoni, M. (2021). Tanzania refuses COVID-19 vaccines. The Lancet, 397(10274), 566.
• Makoye, K. (2013, November 28). Tanzania police set up special desks for gender violence cases. Thomson Reuters Foundation. https://news.trust.org/item/20131128131537-fitsc/
• Makoye, K. (2014, October 16). Donors freeze aid to Tanzania. DW. https://www.dw.com/en/donorsfreeze-aid-to-tanzania/a-17999275
• Manji, A. (1998). Gender and the politics of the land reform process in Tanzania. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 36(4), 645–667.
• Mbilinyi, M. (2015). Transformative Feminism in Tanzania: Animation and Grassroots Women’s Struggles for Land and Livelihoods. In R. Baksh, & W. Harcourt (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Transnational Feminist Movements (pp. 507–528). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Melesse, T., & Awel, Y. (2020). Land tenure, gender, and productivity in Ethiopia and Tanzania. In M. Konte, & N. Tirivay (Eds.), Women and Sustainable Human Development (pp. 89–108). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Mercer, C. (1999). Reconceptualizing state-society relations in Tanzania: Are NGOs ‘making a difference’? Area, 31(3), 247–258.
• Mkumbo, K. (2015). Ten Years of Jakaya Kikwete’s Presidency in Tanzania: Analysis of Promises, achievements and challenges in education. The African Review: A Journal of African Politics, Development and International Affairs, 42(2), 40–62.
• Muvunyi, F. (2016, May 12). Tanzania’s Magufuli leads fight against corruption. DW. https://www.dw.com/en/tanzanias-magufuli-leads-fight-against-corruption/a-19252614
• Mwaipopo, R. (2021). Women, Land Tenure Dynamics and Land Sales in Rural Areas. The Case of Syukula Village, Tanzania. The African Review, 48(2), 476–506.
• Nonjinge, G. (2018). Gender equality in Tanzania: Uproar and perceived progress. Afrobarometer Dispatch, 237.
• Nyaluke, D., & Connolly, E. (2013). The Role of Political Ideas in Multi-Party Elections in Tanzania: Refuting Essentialist Explanations of African Political Systems. Irish Studies in International Affairs, 24(1), 41–57.
• Ogunjewo, H. (2022). John Magufuli and Tanzania’s Rebirth: Any Lessons for Africa? Ihafa: A Journal of African Studies, 13(1), 199–215.
• Paget, D. (2017). Tanzania: Shrinking Space and Opposition Protest. Journal of Democracy, 28(3), 163–166.
• Peeples, A. (2019). Women’s Works: The Evolution of Tanzanian Women’s Movements from Late Colonialism to Post-Structural Adjustment. Global Africana Review, 3(1), 21–31.
• Phillips, K. (2010). Pater Rules Best: Political Kinship and Party Politics in Tanzania’s Presidential Elections. Political and Legal Anthropology Review, 33(1), 109–132.
• Polus, A. (2018). Polityka Tanzanii wobec EAC w kontekście negocjacji Umów o Partnerstwie Gospodarczym. In A. Mania, M. Grabowski, & J. Mormul (Eds.), Problemy regionalne Azji, Afryki i Bliskiego Wschodu u progu XXI wieku. Warszawa: Rambler.
• Polus, A., Kopiński, D., & Tycholiz, W. (2021). Reproduction and convertibility: examining wealth inequalities in South Africa. Third World Quarterly, 42(2), 292–311.
• Poncian, J. (2010). Galvanising political support through resource nationalism: A case of Tanzania’s 2017 extractive sector reforms. Political Geography, 69, 77–88.
• Ratcliffe, R. (2017, June 30). After getting pregnant, you are done’: no more school for Tanzania’s mumsto- be. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2017/jun/30/tanzaniapresident-ban-pregnant-girls-from-school-john-magufuli
• Reay, D. (2004). Gendering Bourdieu’s Concepts of Capitals? Emotional Capital, Women and Social Class. The Sociological Review, 52, 57–74.
• Reilly, N. (Ed.). (2009). Gender and NGOs: Feminist perspectives. Zed Books.
• Reuters. (2017, July 21). Tanzania’s Magufuli threatens to shut mines if firms delay tax talk. https://www.reuters.com/article/tanzania-mining-idINL5N1KC32Z
• TGNP. (2015). Election Manifesto of Constitution and Election Women Coalition.
• The Economist. (2007, August 30). President Kikwete’s hard road ahead. https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2007/08/30/president-kikwetes-hard-road-ahead
• The Economist Intelligence Unit. (2017, April 4). Magufuli is making enemies in the CCM. http://country.eiu.com/article.aspx?articleid=1275288711&Country
• The Guardian. (2019, October 29). Tanzania president Magufuli condemned for authoritarian regime. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2019/oct/29/tanzania-president-magufulicondemned-for-authoritarian-stance
• The Guardian. (2021, September 18). We cannot fail millions of children who need better education – JK. https://www.ippmedia.com/en/news/we-cannot-fail-millions-children-who-need-better-education-jk
• The Millennium Development Goals. (2000).
• Therkildsen, O. (2014). Working in Neopatrimonial Settings: Public Sector Staff Perceptions in Tanzania and Uganda. In T. Bierschenk & J.-P. Oliver de Sardan (Eds.), States at Work. Dynamics of African Bureaucracies (pp. 113–144). The Netherlands: Brill.
• Tripp, A. M. (1994). Gender, Political Participation and the Transformation of Associational Life in Uganda and Tanzania. African Studies Review, 37(1), 107–131.
• Tripp, A. M. (2000). Political Reform in Tanzania: The Struggle for Associational Autonomy. Comparative Politics, 32(2), 191–214.
• Tripp, A. M. (2003). Forging Developmental Synergies Between States and Associations. In N. van de Walle et al. (Eds.), Beyond Structural Adjustment (pp. 131–158). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Tripp, A. M., et al. (Eds.). (2011). African Women’s Movements: Transforming Political Landscapes: Changing Political Landscapes. Cambridge–New York: Cambridge University Press.
• Wacquant, L. (2018). Four transversal principles for putting Bourdieu to work. Anthropological Theory, 18(1), 3–17.
• World Bank. (n.d.). GDP growth (annual %) – Tanzania. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG?locations=TZ
• Wuyts, M., & Kilama, B. (2014). The changing economy of Tanzania: patterns of accumulation and structural change. REPOA, Working Paper 14/3.
• UNFPA Tanzania. (2018). Fact Sheet: Teenage Pregnancy.
• Zinsser, J. (2002). From Mexico to Copenhagen to Nairobi: The United Nations Decade for Women, 1975–1985. Journal of World History, 13(1), 139–168.
• Yaziji, M., & Doh, J. (2011). Organizacje pozarządowe a korporacje. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN.
• Gratian, B. (2016, September 5). Interview with Bamwenda Gratian, Tanzania Academy of Sciences – TAAS.
• Rennie, G. (2015, September 25). Interview with Godwe Rennie, Ministry of Health, Community Development, Gender, Elderly and Children.
• Eugenia, K. (2015, September 27). Interview with Kafanabo Eugenia, Gender Center.
• Leonida, K. (2016, September 6). Interview with Kanyuma Leonida, Tanzania Media Women’s Association – TAMWA.
• Marcel, K. (2015, September 23). Interview with Katemba Marcel, Ministry of Health, Community Development, Gender, Elderly and Children.
• Anna, K. (2016, September 1). Interview with Kikwa Anna, Tanzania Gender Networking Programme – TGNP.
• Rehema, M. (2015, September 25). Interview with Msami Rehema, Women’s Legal Aid Center – WLAC.
• Victoria, M. (2015, September 23). Interview with Munene Victoria, Pact Tanzania.
• Leonce, N. A. (2016, September 6). Interview with Ndunguru Aureus Leonce, Tanzania Women Chamber of Commerce – TWCC.
• Richard, N. (2016, September 20). Interview with Ngilangwa Richard, Research Assistant, Economic and Social Research Foundation.
• Jaliath, R. (2016, September 8). Interview with Rangi Jaliath, Medical Women Association of Tanzania – MEWATA.
• Mary, R. (2016, September 2). Interview with Rusimbi Mary, Women Fund Tanzania.
• Rose, S. (2015, September 22). Interview with Shayo Rose, University of Dar es Salaam.
• Anna, S. (2015, September 23 and 2016, September 6). Interview with Stainsby Anna, Policy Forum.
• Ngunga, T. (2016, September 7). Interview with Tepani Ngunga, Tanzania Organization of Non-Governmental Organizations – TANGO.
• Nimila, W. (2016, September 1). Interview with Watson Nimila, Tanzania Women Lawyers Association – TAWLA.