The Present and Future of Local Self-Government in the Republic of Kazakhstan

After the collapse of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), Kazakhstan’s policymakers recognized that the existing model of state governance had proved ineffective and needed to be changed. One of the necessary solutions was to carry out decentralization. The primary purpose of the following article is to outline the barriers that Kazakhstan needs to remove if it is serious about building local self-government independence. Confronting these with the President’s vision of the transformation of local self-government led to the following research questions: What organizational and legal issues remain unresolved or constitute a barrier to the construction of independent local government structures in the Republic of Kazakhstan after the collapse of the Soviet Union?; to what extent do the changes proposed by President Kasym Tokayev meet the real challenges in the context of expanding the autonomy of local power structures? Answering the questions posed was possible by analyzing legal acts and finding literature and press materials.

REFERENCES:

• «Akim dolžen ponjat' i prinjat' mysl' o tom, čto on stal bol'še zaviset' ot naselenija». (2021, August 5). [“Akim must understand and accept the idea that he has become more dependent on the population.”]. Soros. kz. https://www.soros.kz/ru/the-first-direct-elections-of-rural-akims-were-held-in-kazakhstan/
• Alzhanov, D. (2021). Kazakhstan: The Visibility of Local Self-Government Reforms Only Multiplies Problems in the Regions. CabarAsia. https://cabar.asia/en/kazakhstan-the-visibility-of-local-selfgovernment-reforms-only-multiplies-problems-in-the-regions
• Bitoleuova, Y., Lavrovsky, B., Alimbetov, U, & Turdiyeva, Z. (2022). Current state of the local self-government budgeting in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Bulletin of „Turan” University, 2, 295–304.
• Bisztyga, A. (2014). Terenowa administracja rządowa oraz samorząd terytorialny w Republice Kazachstanu. Aspekt Konstytucyjny. Studia Iuridica Lublinensia, 22, 179–198.
• Central'naja izbiratel'naja komissija Respubliki Kazahstan. Vybory akimov gorodov rajonnogo značenija, sel'skih okrugov, poselkov i sel Respubliki Kazakhstan [Elections of akims of cities of district significance, rural districts, towns and villages of the Republic of Kazakhstan]. https://www.election.gov.kz/rus/informatsiya-o-vyborakh-i-referendumakh-v-rk/informatsiya-o-proshedshikh-izbiratelnykhkampaniyakh/vybory-akimov-gorodov-rayonnogo-znacheniya-selskikh-okrugov-poselkov-i-selrespubliki-kazakhstan.php
• Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan of August 30, 1995.
• Duisenov, E., Kalisheva, N., Zholat, Y., & Kaliskarov, Y. (2015). Some Constitutional and Legal Issues for Local Self-Government Development in Kazakhstan. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 6(4), 294–300.
• Europejska Karta Samorządu Terytorialnego. (1985).
• Graždanskij bjudžet Aktogajskogo sel'skogo okruga na 2021–2023 gody [Civil budget of Aktogay rural district for 2021–2023]. Budget.gov.kz. https://budget.egov.kz/budgetfile/file?fileId=1685936
• Graždanskij bjudžet Rajymbeksogo sel'skogo okruga Karasajskogo rajona 2020 god. [Civil budget of Raiymbek rural district of Karasai district 2020]. Budget.gov.kz. https://budget.egov.kz/budgetfile/file?fileId=1302955
• Grochmalski, P. (2006). Kazakhstan. Studium Politologiczne. Warszawa.
• Jarosiewicz, A. (2016). Pierestrojka Nazarbajewa. Kryzys i reformy w Kazachstanie. Warszawa.
• Junussova, M. (2017). Local Government and Economic Development in Kazakhstan. Ottawa, Ontario.
• Kajsar, A. (2022, February 17). Tokaev zajavil, čto vybory rajonnyh akimov mogut projti v 2023 godu v kačestve pilotnogo proekta [Tokayev said that elections of district akims could be held in 2023 as a pilot project]. Vlast. kz. https://vlast.kz/novosti/48709-tokaev-zaavil-cto-vybory-rajonnyh-akimovmogut-projti-v-2023-godu-v-kacestve-pilotnogo-proekta.html
• Knox, C., & Janenova S. (2018). Public Councils in Kazakhstan: A case of emergent participative democracy? Central Asian Survey, 37(2), 305–321.
• Mazorenko, D. Tokaev ob''javil o perehode Kazahstana k sisteme mestnogo samoupravlenija [Tokayev announced the transition of Kazakhstan to a system of local self-government]. https://vlast.kz/novosti/49169-tokaev-obavil-o-perehode-kazahstana-k-sisteme-mestnogo-samoupravlenia.html
• Midel'skij, S. (2014). Kratkaja istorija mestnogo samoupravlenija v Kazahstane: tradicii i tendencii. Pavlodar.
• Nurmakov, A. (2022, January 28). Bezučastnyj «Bjudžet učastija» [Indifferent “Participation Budget”]. Kursiv.kz. https://kz.kursiv.media/opinions/bezuchastnyj-bjudzhet-uchastiya/
• Onulbaiuly, S. (2019). Democratisation of Local Government and Local Governance in Kazakhstan. Cambridge.
• Osipova, I. (2021, August 8). V Kazahstane zamedlilsja rost čisla NPO [Growth in NGOs slowed down in Kazakhstan]. Kursiv. https://kz.kursiv.media/2021-08-04/v-kazakhstane-zamedlilsya-rost-chisla-npo/
• Podgłódek, A. (2017). Referendum ogólnokrajowe w Republice Kazachstanu. Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne, 3, 159–176.
• Poslanie Glavy gosudarstva Kasym-Žomarta Tokaeva narodu Kazahstana. Novyj Kazahstan: put' obnovlenija i modernizacii om 16 marta 2022 goda [Message of the Head of State Kassym-Jomart Tokayev to the people of Kazakhstan. New Kazakhstan: the path of renewal and modernization om March 16, 2022].
• Postanovlenie Mežparlamentskoj Assamblei gosudarstv – učastnikov Sodružestva Nezavisimyh Gosudarstv N 14-15 «O model'nom zakone «O mestnom referendume»
• Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Respubliki Kazahstan ot 9 sentjabrja 1996 g. N 1097 O Koncepcii regional'noj politiki Respubliki Kazakhstan [Decree of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 9, 1996, N 1097 On the Concept of Regional Policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan]. https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P960001097_
• Sikora-Gaca, M. (2012). Proces demokratyzacji i budowy społeczeństwa obywatelskiego w Azji Centralnej. In L. Kacprzak, B. Koszel, & A. Marcinkowski (Eds.), Społeczeństwo obywatelskie jako dobro wspólne. Piła.
• Soltangazinov, A. (2012). Regional'naja politika obespečenija ustojčivogo razvitija sel'skih territorij [Regional policy to ensure sustainable development of rural areas]. Vestnik Innovacionnogo Evrazijskogo universiteta. https://articlekz.com/article/13257
• Sud'ba samovydviženca, ili Čemu učat vybory akima v sele Saryomir. (2022, February 2). [The fate of a self-nominated candidate, or what the elections of Akim in the village of Saryomir teach]. Radio Azattyk. https://rus.azattyq.org/a/vybory-akima-sela-saryomir-kak-kvintessentsiya-demokraticheskoyreformy/31623138.html
• Szymanek, J. (2022). Ustrój Konstytucyjny Kazachstanu. Warszawa.
• Ukaz Prezidenta Respubliki Kazahstan ot 18 avgusta 2021 goda № 639. Ob utverždenii Koncepcii razvitija mestnogo samoupravlenija v Respublike Kazahstan do 2025 goda [Decree of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 18, 2021 No. 639. On approval of the Concept for developing local self-government in the Republic of Kazakhstan until 2025].
• Uruzgaliyeva, M., & Bukharbayev, S. (2017). Development features and decentralization problem of regional budgets in Kazakhstan. Journal of Modern Science, 4(35). 133–145.
• Utibaev, B., & Utibaeva, G. (2022). Improvement of the local self-government system in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Problems of AgriMarket, 1(1), 67–74.
• Yuvitsa, N. (2019). Local government in Kazakhstan: an attempt to create a national model. Upravlenie / Management, 7(1), 26–34.
• V kakom regione prisutstvovalo bol'še vsego nabljudatelej na vyborah sel'skih akimov v RK (2021, December 27). [ In which region were the most observers present at the elections of rural akims in the Republic of Kazakhstan]. KazInform. https://www.inform.kz/ru/v-kakom-regione-prisutstvovalobol-she-vsego-nablyudateley-na-vyborah-sel-skih-akimov-v-rk_a3878854
• V Kazahstane oficial'no pojavilis' tri novye oblasti (2022, June 08). [Three new regions officially appeared in Kazakhstan]. Tengrinews. https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/v-kazahstane-ofitsialno-poyavilistri-novyie-oblasti-470481/
• Vybory akimov rajonov sostojatsja v 2024 godu – Tokaev. (2021, September 1). [Elections of akims of districts to be held in 2024 – Tokayev]. TengriNews. https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/vyiboryi-akimov-rayonov-sostoyatsya-v-2024-godu-tokaev-447318/
• Zhumashov, Y. (2019). Rural Local Government System in Kazakhstan: Recent Issues. International Review of Management and Marketing, 6(S5), 211–220.
• Zhumashov, Y. (2022). An Exploration of Vertical and Social Accountability in the Elected Tier of Local Government Evidence from Kazakhstan. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 1–15.