Fake Solidarity? Actions Taken by the Russian Opposition Since the Outbreak of Full-Scale War in Ukraine

The article aims to show the actions the Russian nonsystemic opposition took after the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine. We prove that the Russian opposition has been deeply divided since that time. It includes various leaders and factions who want to play an essential role in post-Putin Russia. It also presents multiple opinions on Russia’s internal and external policies. On the other hand, since the outbreak of war in Ukraine, the Russian opposition has been more visible both in Eastern and Western Europe. The article is divided into two parts. In the first part, we establish the genesis of the current nonsystemic opposition in Russia and its exile. We also present the most well-known oppositionists in the Russian political scene. In the second part, we analyze the meetings and conferences of the Russian opposition in exile from March 2022 to February 2024. It enables us to find the plans of the Russian opposition for rebuilding a political system in post-Putin Russia. The article is based on desk research, historical methods, and thematic analysis.

REFERENCES:

• Aleksiejev, I. (2023, February 26). Rossiyu pereimenuyut, a Moskva ne budet stolitsey? Kak proshel 2-y S’’yezd narodnykh deputatov. Bielsat.ru. https://belsat.eu/ru/news/26–02–2023-rossiyu-pereimenuyut-a-moskva-ne-budet-stolitsej-kak-proshel-2-j-sezd-narodnyh-deputatov [Россию переименуют, а Москва не будет столицей? Как прошел 2-й Съезд народных депутатов].
• Anti-War Conference. (2022, March 3). Free Russia Institute. https://www.freerussiainstitute.com/ events/2022/03/03/anti-war-conference/
• II Anti-War Conference. (2022, May 22). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/archivesen/forum-awcii-en
• III Anti-War Conference. (2022, November 30 – December 1). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/archives-en/forum-awciii-en
• Bagashka, T. (2012). Presidentialism and the development of party systems in hybrid regimes: Russia 2000–2002. Europe-Asia Studies, 64(1), 91–113. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09668136.2011.635891
• Benedyczak, J. (2022, November 9). Prank „rosyjskiej opozycji” w Warszawie. Instytut Nowej Europy. https://ine.org.pl/prank-rosyjskiej-opozycji-w-warszawie/
• Bertrand, E. (2021). Opposition in a hybrid regime: The functions of opposition parties in Burkina Faso and Uganda. African Affairs, 120(481), 591–610. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/afraf/adab023
• Bierries, L. (2023, July 20). Uciekli do Polski. Rosja uzna Zjazd Delegatów Ludowych w Warszawie za ekstremistyczny. Bielsat.pl. https://belsat.eu/pl/news/20–07–2023-uciekli-do-polski-rosja-uznazjazd-delegatow-ludowych-w-warszawie-za-ekstremistyczny
• Bilonozhko, Y., & Shlinchak, V. (2022, November 10) Ubyty Putina. Yak proishov pershyi «Zizd narodnykh deputativ.» Glavcom. https://glavcom.ua/publications/ubiti-putina-jak-projshov-pershij-zjizdnarodnikh-deputativ-888194.html [Є. Білоножко, В. Шлінчак, Убити Путіна. Як пройшов перший «З’їзд народних депутатів].
• Bol’shakov, I. (2012). The nonsystemic opposition. Russiam Politics & Law, 50(3), 82–92. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2753/RUP1061–1940500306
• Casani, A. (2020). Cross-ideological coalitions under authoritarian regimes: Islamist–Left collaboration among Morocco’s excluded opposition. Democratization, 27(7), 1183–1201. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2020.1772236
• Chaisty, P., & Whitefield, S. (2013). Forward to democracy or back to authoritarianism? The attitudinal bases of mass support for the Russian election protests of 2011–2012, Post-Soviet Affairs, 29(5), 387–403. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1060586X.2013.807605
• Chernova, A., Edwards, C., & Shortell, D. (2024, February 16). Jailed Russian opposition figure Alexey Navalny dies, prison service says. CNN. https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/16/europe/alexey-navalnydead-russia-prison-intl/index.html
• Dahl, R. A. (Ed.). (1966). Political opposition in Western Democracies. New Haven: Yale University Press.
• Declaration of Russian Democratic Forces (2023, April 30). Change.org. http://surl.li/qujlo
• Denisyuk, V. (2022, October 22). S’’yedyat ikru i vyp’yut vodki”: Davidyuk predpolozhil, chego zhdat’ otkongressa rossiyan v Pol’she. Kanal 24. https://24tv.ua/ru/rossijskaja-oppozicija-sobiraetsja-varshave-kakaja-polza-ot-takih_n2182618 [“Съедят икру и выпьют водки”: Давидюк предположил, чего ждать от конгресса россиян в Польше].
• Deokupatsiia Ukrainy, usunennia Putina, sud nad viiskovymy zlochyntsiamy i reparatsii, – spilna deklaratsiia opozytsioneriv RF (2023, May 2). Espreso. https://espreso.tv/deokupatsiya-ukrainiusunennya-putina-sud-nad-viyskovimi-zlochintsyami-i-reparatsii-spilna-deklaratsiya-opozitsioneriv-rf [Деокупація України, усунення Путіна, суд над військовими злочинцями і репарації, – спільна декларація опозиціонерів РФ].
• Dettmer, J. (2024, February 21). Russia’s opposition died with Navalny. Politico. https://www.politico.eu/article/russias-opposition-died-with-navalny/
• Dmitriyev, S. (2023, March 2). «Rossiyskaya respublika» v Varshave: v Pol’she proshel Vtoroy S’’yezd rossiyskikh deputatov. Rfi. http://surl.li/rdnha [Сергей Дмитриев „Российская республика” в Ва ршаве: в Польше прошел Второй Съезд российских депутатов].
• Elder, M. (2011, December 10). Russians come out in force to protest against alleged electoral fraud. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/dec/10/russia-protests-election-vladimir-putin
• Eliseeva, N. (2016). The “New” Non-systemic Opposition in Russia. World Science, 4(2).
• XII Forum (2024, February 23–24). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/archives-en/ forum-xii-en
• Gelman, V. (2015). Political transformation in Russia: A troubled transformation. Europe-Asia Studies, 67(2), 177–191. DOI: 10.1080/09668136.2014.1001577
• Gelman, V. (2005). Political opposition in Russia: A dying species? Post-Soviet Affairs, 21(2), 226–246. DOI: 10.2747/1060–586X.21.3.226
• Grala, H. (2023, June 14). Spojrzenie na Wschód. O wojnie z Putinem i nowej Rosji. Zjazd Deputowanych Ludowych w Warszawie. Interview with Polskie Radio 24. Polskie Radio 24. https://polskieradio24.pl/artykul/3189265,o-wojnie-z-putinem-i-nowej-rosji-zjazd-deputowanych-ludowychw-warszawie
• Hartog, E., & Goryashko, S. (2024, February 17). Now it’s for real: Navalny is dead, his team confirms. Politico. https://www.politico.eu/article/alexei-navalny-russia-is-officially-dead-his-team-confirms/
• Helms, L. (2023). Political oppositions in democratic and authoritarian regimes: A state-of-the-field(s) review. Government and Opposition, 58(2), 391–414. DOI: 10.1017/gov.2022.25
• Helms, L. (Ed.). (2016). Parliamentary opposition in old and new democracies. Routledge.
• Irpin Declaration on the cooperation of Russian opposition against Putin’s regime. (2022, September 1). Kyiv Post. https://www.kyivpost.com/post/5321
• Iryna. (2023, June 9). Rosiiska opozytsiia zidetsia do Varshavy, shchob podumaty nad maibutnim RF i zvernutysia do polskoho narodu. The Warsow. https://www.the-warsaw.com/uk/70406/rosijskaopozicija-z-idetsja-do-varshavi-shhob-podumati-nad-majbutnim-rf-i-zvernutisja-do-polskogonarodu/ [Російська опозиція з’їдеться до Варшави, щоб подумати над майбутнім РФ і звернутися до польського народу].
• Kasparov, G. (2023, February 18). Russia Reimagined: Visions for a Democratic Future. An interview during Munich Security Conference 2023. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2023/agenda/ event/russia-reimagined-visions-for-a-democratic-future/
• Khodorkovsky, M. (2023, June 5).The future of Russia – and its opposition. Politico. https://www.politico. eu/article/future-of-russia-and-its-opposition-conference-brussels/
• Khodorkovsky, M. (2023, February 18). Russia reimagined: Visions for a democratic future. An interview during Munich Security Conference 2023. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2023/agenda/event/russia-reimagined-visions-for-a-democratic-future/
• König, T., Lin, N., & Silva, T. N. (2023). Government dominance and the role of opposition in parliamentary democracies. European Journal of Political Research, 62, 594–611.
• Kucher, S. (2024, February 17). Experts break down suspicious timing of Navalny’s death. CNN. https:// youtube.com/watch?v=SKVNK9xxAI4
• Laštro, C., & Bieber, F. (2021). The performance of opposition parties in competitive authoritarian regimes: Three case studies from the Western Balkans. European Political Science, 20(4), 617–629. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304–021–00326-w
• Litvinova, D. (2024, February 18). ‘Over 400 detained in Russia’ as country mourns death of Putin critic Alexei Navalny. Time. https://time.com/6696285/alexei-navalny-death-russia-people-detainedtributes/
• Madrid, R. L. (2019). Opposition parties and the origins of democracy in Latin America. Comparative Politics, 51(2), 157–178. DOI: 10.5129/001041519825256641
• Matviychuk, M. (2023, August 21). You can’t turn the stuffing back: what Navalny said about the occupied Crimea. Suspline Crimea. https://crimea.suspilne.media/en/news/942
• Meka, E. (2022). How much opposition? Political fragmentation and changes in democracy. Contemporary Politics, 28(5), 517–538. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13569775.2021.2015086
• Mironov, M. (2023, December 19). Time for Ukraine to work with the Russian opposition. Politico. https://www.politico.eu/article/time-ukraine-work-with-russia-opposition/
• Moscow protest: Thousands rally against Vladimir Putin. (2011, December 25). BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-16324644
• Munich Security Conference Agenda and Participants. (2015). Munich Security Conference. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2015/agenda/
• The Munich Security Conference 2023 at a Glance. (2023). Munich Security Conference. https://securityconference.org/en/publications/munich-security-brief/searching-for-a-common-vision/at-a-glance/
• Nadskakuła-Kaczmarczyk, O. (2019). Kapitał polityczny opozycji antysystemowej w Rosji. Księgarnia Akademicka.
• Nadskakuła-Kaczmarczyk, O. (2017). Russian nonsystemic opposition as an enemy in pro-Kremlin media. Studia politologiczne, 44, 307–320. http://www.studiapolitologiczne.pl/Russian-Non-SystemicOpposition-as-an-Enemy-nin-pro-Kremlin-Media,115641,0,1.html
• Navalnaya, Y. (2024, February 16). A message from Yulia Navalnaya. A speech during the Munich Security Conference 2024. Munich Security Conference. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2024/ agenda/event/a-message-from-yulia-navalnaya/
• Nemtsova, Z. (2024, February 17). The future of Russia. An interview during Munich Security Conference 2024. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2024/agenda/event/spotlight-russia/
• Ouzilevski, A. (2023, April 24). In Warsaw, the Russian ‘Parliament in exile’ debates a post-Putin future. Institute of Current World Affairs. https://www.icwa.org/russian-parliament-in-exile-debates/
• Papachristou, L. (2024, February 19). What we know about Alexei Navalny’s death in an Arctic prison. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/alexei-navalnys-death-what-do-weknow-2024–02–18/
• Persson, T., Karlsson, C., Lehmann, F., & Mårtensson, M. (2024). Drivers of parliamentary opposition in European Union politics: institutional factors or party characteristics? Journal of European Public Policy, 31(3), 756–781. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2022.2162567
• Proty viiny i rezhymu Putina: rosiiski opozytsionery u Yevropi ukhvalyly deklaratsiiu. (2023, May 1). Politerno. https://politerno.com.ua/2023/05/01/proty-vijny-i-rezhymu-putina-rosijski-opozytsioneryu-yevropi-uhvalyly-deklaratsiyu/#
• Resolution of the Free Russia Forum. (2023, October 3). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/announcements/2023–10–03/resolution-of-the-free-russia-forum
• Resolution of the 4th Anti-War Conference. (2023, March 25). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/announcements/2023–03–25/resolution-of-the-4th-anti-war-conference
• Resolution of the Third Anti-War Conference. (2022, December 8). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/announcements/2022–12–08/resolution-of-the-third-anti-war-conference
• Resolution of the Free Russia Forum on Lukashenka’s statement about Russia’s ownership of Crimea. (2021, December 15). Free Russia Forum. https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/documentsen/2021–12–15/resolution-of-the-free-russia-forum-on-lukashenkas-statement-about-russiasownership-of-crimea
• Resolution of the Second Free Russia Forum. (2016, October 14–15). https://www.forumfreerussia.org/en/archives-en/forum-ii-en
• Rosenberg, S., & Armstrong, K. (2023, April 17). Vladimir Kara-Murza: Russian opposition figure jailed for 25 years. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-65297003
• Rosiiski opozytsionery v Yevropi ukhvalyly deklaratsiiu proty viiny v Ukraini ta rezhymu Putina. Soratnyky Navalnoho zustrich proihnoruvaly. (2023, May 1). Gordon. https://gordonua.com/ukr/news/worldnews/rosijski-opozitsioneri-v-jevropi-uhvalili-deklaratsiju-proti-vijni-v-ukrajinita-rezhimu-putina-1661995.html [Російські опозиціонери в Європі ухвалили декларацію проти війни в Україні та режиму Путіна. Соратники Навального зустріч проігнорували].
• Rosiiska opozytsiia zibralasia v Yevroparlamenti v Briusseli – detali. (2023, June 5). 5Freedom. https://uatv.ua/uk/rosijska-opozytsiya-zibralasya-v-yevroparlamenti-v-bryusseli-detali-video/ [Російська опозиція зібралася в Європарламенті в Брюсселі — деталі].
• Roth, A. (2024, February 16). Western leaders point finger at Putin after Alexei Navalny’s death in jail. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/feb/16/russian-activist-and-putincritic-alexei-navalny-dies-in-prison
• Russia: Police detain thousands in pro-Navalny protests. (2021, January 25). Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/01/25/russia-police-detain-thousands-pro-navalny-protests
• Russian oppositionists unite adopt political program. (2022, November 9). Kyiv Post. https://www.kyivpost.com/post/4925
• Schulmann, E. (2024, February 17). The future of Russia. An interview during Munich Security Conference 2024. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2024/agenda/event/spotlight-russia/
• Shea, P., Teo, T.K., & Levy, J. S. (2014). Opposition politics and international crises: A formal model. International Studies Quarterly, 58, 741–751. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1658695
• Shcherbakova, I. (2024, February 17). The future of Russia. An interview during Munich Security Conference 2024. Munich Security Conference. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2024/agenda/event/spotlight-russia/
• Shlinchak, V. (2023, March 28). Hlukhyi kut rosiiskoi opozytsii. Reportazh z Antyvoiennoi konferentsii. Glavcom. https://glavcom.ua/publications/hlukhij-kut-rosijskoji-opozitsiji-reportazh-z-antivojennojikonferentsiji-917235.html [В. Шлінчак, Глухий кут російської опозиції. Репортаж з Антивоєнної конференції].
• Stepanenko, M. (2023, May 5). Deklaratsiia «rosiiskoi opozytsii» u vyhnanni. Shcho tse bulo i na koho rozrakhovano? http://surl.li/qukcn [М. Степаненко, Декларація «російської опозиції» у вигнанні. Що це було і на кого розраховано?].
• Stone, B. (2014). Opposition in parliamentary democracies: A framework for comparison. Australasian Parliamentary Review, 29(1), 19–31.
• Szoszyn, R. (2023, February 8). O Rosji w Warszawie. Przeciwnicy Kremla znów zbiorą się w Polsce. Rzeczpospolita. https://www.rp.pl/polityka/art37917931-o-rosji-w-warszawie-przeciwnicy-kremlaznow-zbiora-sie-w-polsce
• „Toi samyi dyiavol”: Zelenskyi pro rosiisku opozytsiiu (2023, December 2). Espress TV. https://espreso. tv/toy-samiy-diyavol-zelenskiy-pro-rosiysku-opozitsiyu
• Tretie zasidannia zizdu rosiiskoi opozytsii startuvalo u Varshavi – detali. (2023, June 6). Freedom. https://uatv.ua/uk/tretye-zasidannya-rosijskoyi-opozytsiyi-startuvalo-u-varshavi-detali-video/ [Третє засідання з’їзду російської опозиції стартувало у Варшаві — деталі].
• Troianovski, A. (2021, August 31). Exile or jail: The grim choice facing Russian opposition leaders. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/30/world/europe/russian-opposition-leaders-exile.html
• Turovsky, R. (2015). The systemic opposition in authoritarian regimes: A case study of Russia’s regions. In C. Ross (Ed.), The systemic and nonsystemic opposition in the Russian Federation: National and regional dimensions (pp. 121–137). Routledge.
• Von Kasakow, E. (2023, September 7). Opposition im Exil: Das Fell des Bären wird schon verteilt. Woz die Wochenzeitung. https://www.woz.ch/2336/opposition-im-exil/das-fell-des-baeren-wird-schonverteilt/!KBB3FM9MTRRN
• White, D. (2011). Dominant party systems: A framework for conceptualizing opposition strategies in Russia. Democratization, 18(3), 655–681. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2011.563122
• Zelensky, V. (2024, February 17). Ukraine in the world. A speech during the Munich Security Conference 2024. Munich Security Conference. https://securityconference.org/en/msc-2024/agenda/event/ ukraine-in-the-world/