The Ukrainian Crisis as a Case Study of Different Policymaking Styles of Russia and China

The Ukrainian crisis of 2014 has been a popular theme of journal and media articles for obvious reasons. Its “Chinese”, or rather Sino-Russian dimension has been less so, though the Chinese reaction to the Ukrainian crisis and the implications of this reaction represent interesting political phenomenon. This article tries to fill this gap and uses the description of Russia and China policies during the crisis as a case study of Moscow and Beijing political behavior on the international scene in general. Its thesis is that the Ukrainian crisis represents a great case study of these behaviors. Moreover, this case is also a supplement to the general discussion in the field about the state of Russia-China contemporary political relations.

References:

• Chong-Pin Lin (2006). China and International Relations. The Chinese view and the contribution of Wang Gungwu.
• Cohen, D. (2014). “China Maintains Studied Ambiguity On Ukraine As Russia Claims ‘Concordance of Views’”, China Brief, Volume XIV, Issue 5, March 7, 2014.
• de Paal, D.H. (2014). “How Does the Ukraine Crisis Impact China, Carnegie Moscow Formulating China’s Grand Strategy: to dominate, but without fight”, Azja-Pacyfik 9.
• Fu Ying (2015). “How China Sees Russia: Beijing and Moscow Are Close, but Not Allies”, Foreign Policy, 14.12.2015.
• Gabuev, A. (2014). Misreading Asia, Carnegie Center Moscow, 03.06.2014.
• Gabuev, A. (2016). Russia and China: Little Brother or Big Sister?, Moscow Carnegie.
• Gabuev, A. (2017). Friends with Strategic Benefits, Carnegie Moscow, 07.07.2017.
• Jakobsen, L., Holtom, P., Knox, D., and Jingchao Peng (2011). “China’s Energy and Security Relations with Russia. Hopes, Frustrations and Uncertainties“, SIPRI policy paper 29.
• Johnston, A.I. (1998). Cultural Realism: Strategic Culture and Grand Strategy in Chinese.
• Kaczmarski M. (2015). Russia-China Relations in the Post-Crisis International Order.
• Korejba, J. (2014). “Putin wali głową w mur (chiński)” [Putin bangs his head against (Chinese) Wall], Nowa Europa Wschodnia 11.06.2014.
• Kozłowski, K. (2011). Państwo Środka a Nowy Jedwabny Szlak [The Middle Country and the New Silk Road], Toruń, Adam Marszałek.
• Lo, B. (2008). Axis of Convenience. Moscow, Beijing and the New Geopolitics, London, Chatham House.
• Lo, B. (2015). Russia and The New World Disorder, London, Chatham House.
• Lo, B. (2017). A Wary Embrace. What the China-Russia relationship means for the world, Iowy.
• Lo, B., Shevtsova, L. (2012). A 21th Century Myth. Authoritarian Modernization in Russia and China, Carnegie Center Moscow, London–New York, Routledge.
• Lubina, M. (2014). Niedźwiedź w cieniu smoka. Rosja-Chiny 1991 – 2014, Kraków.
• Lubina, M. (2017). Russia and China. A Political Marriage of Convenience, Opladen, Berlin, Toronto: Budrich Publishers.
• Minxin Pei (2013). “China and Russia: Best Frenemies Forever?”, Fortune, 28.03.2013.
• Nation, R.C. (2010). “Russia in East Asia: Aspirations and Limitations”, [in:] Russia’s Prospects in Asia, ed. S. Blank, Carlisle, PA.
• Pyffel, R. (2014). Siedem powodów dla których Chiny nie włączą się w wydarzenia na Ukrainie i pozostaną w ukryciu [Seven Reasons Why China Will Not Join The Events In Ukraine And Will Stay In The Shadow], polska-azja.pl 04.03.2014.
• Rodkiewicz, W. (2014). Putin in Shanghai: a strategic partnership on Chinese terms, OSW.
• Rozman, G. (2014). The Sino-Russian Challenge to the World Order. National Identities, Bilateral Relations, and East Versus West in the 2010s, Woodrow Wilson Center, Stanford Center, 09.04.2015.
• Rumer, E. (2014). China the Winner, Carnegie Center Moscow, 16.06.2014.
• Shen Dingli (2016). “Russian cooperation with China is tactical, not strategic”, Global Times, Stage of All-Encompassing Partnership and Strategic Collaboration] (2014). Kremlin.ru.
• Trenin, D. (2014). Russia-China. The Russian Liberals Revenge, Carnegie Center, 19.05.2014.
• Trenin, D. (2015). From Greater Europe to Greater Asia? The Sino-Russian Entente, Carnegie.
• Trenin, D. (2016). Russia, China Can Help Kashmir Tensions, Carnegie Moscow, 10.10.2016.
• Putin, V. (2013). “A Plea for Caution From Russia”, The New York Times, 11.09.2013.
• Yan Xuetong (2010). Ancient Chinese Thought, Modern Chinese Power, Princeton University.
• Yu Bin (2014 a). “Western Civil War“ Deja Vu?”, Comparative Connections, vol. 16, No. 1.
• Yu Bin (2014 b). “Navigating Through the Ukraine Storm”, Comparative Connections, 15 IX.
• Yu Bin (2016). “Politics of ‘Reluctant Allies’”, Comparative Connections, Vol. 18, No. 2.
• Документы, подписанные в рамках официального визита Президента Российской Федерации В. В. Путина в Китайскую Народную Республику [Documents Signet During President Putin visit to People’s Republic of China] (2014). Kremlin.ru, 20.05.2014.
• Лукин, А.В. (2013). “От нормализации к стратегическому партнерству. Россия и Китай после распада СССР” [From Normalization to Strategic Partnership. Russia and China after USSR’s Fall], [in:] Россия и Китай: четыре века века взаимодействия. История, современное состояние и перспективы развития российско-китайских отношений [RussiaChina Four Centuries of Interaction. History, Contemporary Situation and Perspectives of Development], Под ред А.В. Лукина, Москва.
• Лукьянов, Ф. (2014). “Логичное партнерство” [Logical Partnership], ”Российская газета”, Обращение Президента Российской Федерации [FR President’s Adress] (2014). Kremlin.ru.
• “Российско-Китайская совместная декларация о многополярном мире и формировании нового международного порядка” [Russian-Chinese Joint Declarion on Multipolar World and Forming of New International Order] [in:] Сборник российско-китайских договоров 1949 – 1999. Совместное заявление Российской Федерации и Китайской Народной Республики о новом этапе отношений всеобъемлющего партнерства и стратегического взаимо действия (2014). Joint Declaration of RF and PRC on New Stage of All-Encompassing Partnership and Strategic Colaboration], Kremlin. ru, 20.05.2014.
• Титаренко, М. (2008). Геополитическое значение Дальнего Востока. Россия, Китай и другие страны Азии [The Geopolitical importance of the Far East. Russia, China and the other countries of Asia), Москва.