The specifics of proving causing moral damage to the employee
- Institution: National Academy of Internal Affairs
- ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4365-0495
- Year of publication: 2022
- Source: Show
- Pages: 93-107
- DOI Address: https://doi.org/10.15804/rop2022306
- PDF: rop/21/rop2106.pdf
The article is devoted to causation as one of the main conditions for compensation for moral damage. The specifics of causal link in labor relations are considered and it is established that the theory of direct and indirect causation is the most acceptable from both theoretical and practical perspective for solving the question of its presence or absence. It is proved that an illegal act on the part of the employer should result in moral damage to the latter; if there is no such connection, then, accordingly, the damage to the employee was caused for other reasons, which means that there is no obligation in this legal relationship. Particular attention is paid to primary (direct) and indirect (secondary) moral damage, as moral damage may lie in pain-related experiences or in connection with a disease caused by mental suffering. The process of proving the fact of moral damage and the existence of a causal link, which is quite specific in the employment relationship, is considered. The employee can prove the existence of moral damage by the following means: 1) written, physical and electronic evidence; 2) expert opinion; 3) testimony. Some legal practitioners argue that most labor courts today actually apply the presumption of moral damage, but we do not agree with this conclusion, although we insist on enshrining it in Ukrainian legislation. In our opinion, any lawlessness on the part of the employer affects both the employee’s mental health, i.e. his (her) self-esteem, self-reliance, attitude to the events taking place in his (her) life, etc., and physical health, i.e. the normal functioning of the body. It is proved that it is expedient to involve an expert in every case related to compensation for moral damage in labor relations, whose conclusion is important both in the process of proving the fact of moral damage and determining its amount. Only a specialist is able to properly assess the characteristics of the victim’s behavior in problematic situations and the features of his (her) emotional state under certain circumstances.
REFERENCES:
- Erdelevskyi (2004). Kompensatsiya moralnogo vreda: analiz i kommentariy zakonodatelstva i sudebnoy praktiki [Compensation for moral damage: analysis and commentary on legislation and case law]. Moscow: Volters Kluver.
- Ivasiuk, Ya., Hochachko, I. (2020). Zapytaite yurysta: za shcho pratsivnyk mozhe vymahaty vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody? [Ask the lawyer: for what employee can claim compensation for moral damage?]. The Point (October 20, 2020). Retrieved from: https://kmp.ua/en/analytics/press/ask-a-lawyer-when-does-an-employee-have-theright-to-claim-compensation-for-moral-damage.
- Kapustianskyi, (2005). Pravovyie osnovyi kompensatsii moralnogo vreda [Legal bases of compensation for moral damage]. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Modern Academy of Humanities. Moscow, Russia.
- Kolinko, Ts. (2020). Problemy dovedennia moralnoi shkody za zakonodavstvom Ukrainy [Problems of proving moral damage under the legislation of Ukraine]. Pidpryiemnytstvo, Hospodarstvo i Pravo – Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, 8/2020, 30–34.
- Law of Ukraine No. 1618-IV. Tsyvilnyi protsesualnyi kodeks Ukrainy [Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, March 18, 2004. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1618-15/conv#n9040.
- Law of Ukraine No. 2694-XII. Pro okhoronu pratsi [On Labor Protection]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, October 14, 1992. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2694-12/ed20210814#Text.
- Law of Ukraine No. 322- VIII. Kodeks zakoniv pro pratsiu Ukrainy [Labor Code of Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, December 10, 1971. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada. gov.ua/laws/show/322-08#Text.
- Marszałek-Kawa, J., Plecka, D., Daśko, N. (ed). (2021). Dictionary of Public Institutions. Odessa: Publishing House “Helvetica”.
- Order of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine No. 53/5. Instruktsiia pro pryznachennia ta provedennia sudovykh ekspertyz ta ekspertnykh doslidzhen ta Naukovo-metodychnykh rekomendatsii z pytan pidhotovky ta pryznachennia sudovykh ekspertyz ta ekspertnykh doslidzhen [Instruction on the appointment and conduct of forensic examinations and expert research and Scientific and methodological recommendations for the preparation and appointment of forensic examinations and expert research]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, October 08, 1998. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0705-98#n1556.
- Paniukova, V. (2003). Usloviya kompensaii moralnogo vreda (nekotoryie aspektyi) [Conditions of compensation for moral damage (some aspects)]. Pravo: Teoriya i Praktika – Law: Theory and Practice. Retrieved from: http://www.yurclub.ru/docs/pravo/1603/1.html.
- Polishchuk, V. (2020). Problemy vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody pratsivnyku: advokat Polishchuk [Problems of compensation for moral damage to the employee: lawyer Polishchuk]. Post News Agency. Retrieved from: https://advokatpost.com/problemyvidshkoduvannia-moralnoi-shkody-pratsivnyku-advokat-polishchuk/ [in Ukrainian].
- Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine No. 4. Pro sudovu praktyku v spravakh pro vidshkoduvannia moralnoi (nemainovoi) shkody [On judicial practice in cases of compensation for moral (non-pecuniary) damage]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, March 31, 1995. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v0004700-95#Text.
- Romovska, Z. (2005). Spirni pytannia vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody [Controversial issues of compensation for moral damage]. Visnyk Verkhovnoho sudu Ukrainy –Bulletin of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, 5 (57), pp. 42–43.
- Shevchuk, O. (2020). Vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody v trudovomu pravi [Compensation for moral damage in labor law]. Pravovyi tyzhden – Legal Week, 13 – 24 (December 4, 2020). Retrieved from: http://legalweekly.com.ua/index.php?id=16061&show=news&newsid=121293.
- Shevtsov, S. and Tymoshenko, A. (2011). Vyznachennia rozmiru moralnoi shkody: pravovi zasady ta ekspertni metodyky [Determining the amount of moral damage: legal principles and expert methods]. Kharkiv: Ekspertna sluzhba Ministerstva vnutrishnikh sprav Ukrainy [Expert Service of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine.
- Slipchenko, O. (2010). Dokazy ta dokazuvannia v spravakh pro vidshkoduvannia moralnoi (nemainovoi) shkody [Evidence and proof in cases of compensation for moral damage]. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs. Kharkiv, Ukraine.
causal link employer expert individual features labor relations presumption of moral damage psychological examination victim