Rhetorical Scheme in Georg Philipp Telemann’s Sonatas for Two Violins or Flutes (1727)

Olena Kholodkova Rhetorical Scheme in Georg Philipp Telemann’s Sonatas for Two Violins or Flutes (1727)

The relevance of this article is due to the lack of research of G.Ph. Telemann’s works in the context of Baroque rhetoric. The main purpose of this article is to reveal the content of the Six Sonatas for two violins or flutes by G.Ph. Telemann in the context of the rhetorical scheme. In contrast to the rhetorical figures, the components of the rhetorical canon in a musical piece are not commonly examined in fundamental theorists’ works, and for this reason we suggested to reveal ways of its realization in the G.Ph. Telemann’s duo sonatas. The results of the study have shown that a turn to the rhetorical scheme during the analysis is a completely historical and logical method. The understanding of the subject of musical rhetoric has changed in the historical space, but a great number of Baroque theorists considered the possibility of defining and turning to a rhetorical canon in music, in analogy with verbal rhetoric. The analysis of G.Ph. Telemann’s duo sonatas allows conclusively conclude that they represent four stages of the rhetorical scheme (except the memoria): inventio – as an introduction to a whole composition or as a subject (theme) of a single movement, as well as performer’s improvisation (before or in-between the movements), dispositio – as a specific plan of the form development; decoratio – the use of rhetorical figures and phrases, as well as compositional and performer’s ornamentation and pronuntiatio – methods of sound production, phrasing, dynamics and articulation. The correspondence between G.Ph. Telemann’s music and the rhetorical concept proves not only his profound theoretical knowledge, but also demonstrates the practical use of the rhetorical scheme in his works, which substantiates this analytical approach in this research and also takes researchers and performers to a deeper level of comprehension of the poetics in G.Ph. Telemann’s works.

REFERENCES:

• Asafiev Boris, Muzykalnaya forma kak protsess [Musical Form as a Process], Moscow 1971 (in Russian).
• Bartel Dietrich, Musica Poetica. Musical-Rhetorical Figures in German Baroque Music, Lincoln 1997.
• Bernhard Christoph, Tractatus compositionis augmentatus (1660), edition and Polish translation by Magdalena Walter-Mazur, Kraków 2004.
• Callahan Michael, Techniques of Keyboard Improvisation in the German Baroque and Their Implications for Today’s Pedagogy, (PhD thesis), New York 2010.
• Dikmans Greg, Johann Joachim Quantz on Historically Informed Performance | Early Music and Historically Informed Performance Practice. Retrieved from: http://earlymusic.dikmans.net/quantz-on-historically-informed-performance/ (accessed: 22.08.2022).
• Dreyfus Laurence, Bach and the Patterns of Invention. Cambridge (Mass.)–London 2004.
• Gibson Jonathan, A Kind of Eloquence Even in Music: Embracing Different Rhetorics in Late Seventeenth Century France, “The Journal of Musicology” 2008, vol. 25, no. 4.
• Golomb Uri, Rhetoric in the Performance of Baroque Music, “Goldberg Early Music Magazine” 2008, vol. 51.
• Harrán Don, Toward a Rhetorical Code of Early Music Performance, “The Journal of Musicology” 1997, vol. 15, no. 1.
• Karosi Bàlint, Schemata and Rhetoric: Improvising the Chorale Prelude in the Eighteenth-Century Lutheran Tradition (DMA thesis), New Haven 2014.
• Lampl Hans, A Translation of Syntagma Musicum III by Michael Praetorius (DMA thesis), University of Southern California 1957.
• Lamy Bernard, La rhétorique, ou L’art de parler (1675), Russian translation with preface by E. Pasternak, “Ritorika” B. Lamy v istorii frantsuzskoy filologii [Lamy’s “Rhetoric” in the History of French Philology], Moscow 2002 (in Russian).
• Mattheson Johann, Lenneberg Hans, Johann Mattheson on Affect and Rhetoric in Music (II), “Journal of Music Theory” 1958, vol. 2, no. 2.
• McCreless Patrick, Music and Rhetoric, [in:] “The Cambridge History of Western Music Theory”, ed. Thomas Christensen, Cambridge 2008.
• Mocek Aleksander, Asymilacja idiomów instrumentalnych i wokalnych w kształtowaniu się XVII- i XVIII- -wiecznej praktyki kompozytorskiej i wykonawczej na instrumentach klawiszowych. Od imitatio violistica do cantabile [Assimilation of instrumental and vocal idioms in the formation of 17th- and 18th-century compositional and performance practice on keyboard instruments. From imitatio violistica to cantabile] (PhD thesis), Kraków 2019 (in Polish).
• Pylaeva L., Deystviye printsipov ritoricheskoy dispozitsii v usloviyakh malykh form barokko (na primere frantsuzskikh stsenicheskikh tantsev s peniyem) [The operation of the principles of rhetorical disposition in small forms of Baroque (case study of the French stage dance songs)], “Society: Philosophy, History, Culture” 2015, no. 2.
• Quantz Johann Joachim, Versuch einer Anweisung die Flöte traversière zu spielen (1752), reprint der Ausgabe Berlin, mit einem Vorwort von Hans Peter Schmitz, mit einem Nachwort, Bemerkungen und Registern von Horst Augsbach, Kassel 1980 / Russian translation: J.J.  Quantz, Opyt nastavleniya v igre na fleyte traverso [On Playing The Flute], SPb.: Foundation for the Revival of Early Music 2013 (in Russian).
• Redwood André, Mersenne and the Art of Delivery, “Journal of Music Theory” 2015, vol. 59, no. 1.
• Zawistowski Piotr, Rozważania na temat retoryki w muzyce baroku [Reflections on the Rhetoric in Baroque Music], “Zeszyt Naukowy Filii Akademii Muzycznej w Warszawie” 2003, no. 2 (in Polish).
• Mikołaj Zgółka, Aspekty retoryki w muzyce skrzypcowej [Aspects of rhetoric in violin music], Poznań 2016 (in Polish).